28 York Place Hotel

4.8 out of 5

1159 reviews

0% recommend

4.9 location

4.9 staff/service

4.9 cleanliness

4.7 facilities

Guest from Machynlleth
25th October, 2025

5.0 of 5

Central, clean and comfortable. Staff friendly and helpful. Beautiful view across to the coast. Would have appreciated some museli in the breakfast cereals. Otherwise breakfast was fine.

Ratings

Location

Cleanliness

Staff/Service

Facilities

Would Recommend: Yes

Owner Response

Hi Elen, Thank you for your kind review. We're so pleased to hear you enjoyed our central location, found your room clean and comfortable, and appreciated the warm service from our team. It’s lovely to know the view across added a special touch to your stay. We also appreciate your feedback on breakfast – your suggestion about muesli is a helpful one, and we’ll certainly take it into consideration as we review our offerings. Warm wishes, Alice

Guest from Lossiemouth
13th October, 2025

5.0 of 5

Would not consider staying anywhere else when visiting Edinburgh

Ratings

Location

Cleanliness

Staff/Service

Facilities

Would Recommend: Yes

Tips for other travellers

Stay here, it’s outstanding

Owner Response

Hi Stephen, What a wonderful compliment – thank you so much! We’re truly delighted to know that 28 York Place has become your go-to in Edinburgh. It’s always a pleasure welcoming you and Eileen. We really appreciate your kind recommendation, and look forward to your next visit. Warm wishes, Alice

Guest from Colchester
24th September, 2025

4.8 of 5

Good location, pleasant room and attentive but not overbearing staff. Hot breakfast would have been welcome but I acknowledge that the size of the hotel would make this difficult to offer.

Ratings

Location

Cleanliness

Staff/Service

Facilities

Would Recommend: Yes

Tips for other travellers

For those seeking a good modest sized hotel in a location easily accessible to the main attractions the hotel is ideal. However, not for those preferring a hot breakfast or elderly people who struggle with stairs.

Owner Response

Thank you, Stephen, for your thoughtful review. We’re so pleased you enjoyed our central location, comfortable rooms and the friendly service from our team – it’s lovely to know we made a positive impression. We appreciate your understanding regarding the breakfast offering; you're quite right that, given our size, a hot breakfast is a challenge, but we’re always reviewing. Your helpful tips for fellow travellers are also spot on. We hope to welcome you back next time you're in Edinburgh. Warm wishes, Chloe

Guest from Blandford Forum
23rd September, 2025

4.8 of 5

A very pleasant stay Thankyou

Ratings

Location

Cleanliness

Staff/Service

Facilities

Would Recommend: Yes

Owner Response

Thank you, Gillian – we're so pleased to hear you had a pleasant stay! It was a pleasure to have you with us, and we hope to welcome you back next time you're in Edinburgh. Best wishes, Chloe